Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee Locals Love

Milwaukee’s Italian food scene is defined by the city’s history. From old-school neighborhood delis and family owned restaurants to Sicilian specialties and handmade pasta, Italian restaurants have been a beloved part of Milwaukee’s food culture for generations.

At Milwaukee Food & City Tours, we’ve spent years exploring the city’s most iconic food destinations with tours like our Brady Street Food Tour and others introducing people to the restaurants that make Milwaukee special. Before diving into our full list of favorite Italian restaurants, we wanted to first share a few of our personal must-visits. 

Watch the video below to see our top three Italian restaurants in Milwaukee and the must-try dishes at each!

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Milwaukee Food & City Tours (@mkefoodtour)

Our Top 3 Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee

1. Carini’s

Get Directions: 3468 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211

When we talk about authentic Sicilian food in Milwaukee with our tour guests, Carini’s is always at the top of the list. This restaurant is located on Milwaukee’s North Side and has built a reputation for traditional Sicilian recipes with some of the city’s best wood-fired pizza.

One of our favorite menu items at this spot is the spiedini, a classic Sicilian dish that’s become a house specialty. It’s easy to see why Carini’s earns the top spot with their wood-fired oven and family-owned atmosphere.

2. Glorioso’s Italian Market

Get Directions: 1011 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Some Milwaukee food traditions span generations, and for us, Glorioso’s is one of them. A Brady Street institution for more than 75 years, Glorioso’s has been providing authentic Italian groceries, prepared foods, sandwiches and family recipes to Milwaukeeans for decades. You can experience Glorioso’s for yourself on our Brady Street Food Tour.

The standout? Their famous meatballs. Theresa has been eating Glorioso’s meatballs her entire life and recommends that first-time visitors start with a meatball sandwich.

3. The Pasta Tree Restaurant & Wine Bar

Get Directions: 1503 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

A cornerstone of Milwaukee’s East Side dining scene, The Pasta Tree has built its reputation on handcrafted pasta and a commitment to quality ingredients. This woman-owned restaurant has been delighting guests for generations with homemade dishes that showcase the heart of Italian cooking.

From fresh pasta creations to thoughtfully curated wine pairings, The Pasta Tree continues to be a favorite for date nights, celebrations and anyone looking for an authentic Italian dining experience.

More Great Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee

While our top three are absolute must-visits, Milwaukee’s Italian food scene doesn’t stop there. Here are a few more outstanding places worthy of a spot on any list of the best restaurants in Milwaukee. 

4. Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant

Get Directions: 2995 S Clement Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207

A Milwaukee staple for decades, Tenuta’s serves classic Italian comfort food in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere. Their menu features everything from homemade pasta and chicken parmesan to seafood dishes and traditional Italian desserts. 

5. Calderone Club

Get Directions: 842 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203

Located downtown, the Calderone Club has been serving Italian favorites since 1974. They are known for their pizzas, traditional pasta dishes and charm. It’s also a popular spot before theater performances, sporting events and other downtown nights out.

6. Onesto

Get Directions: 221 N Broadway, Milwaukee, WI 53202

For a more modern take on Italian cuisine, Onesto combines contemporary flavors with traditional techniques. This restaurant located in Milwaukee’s Historic Third Ward is known for its handmade pasta, wood-fired pizzas and stylish atmosphere. 

7. Santino’s Little Italy

Get Directions: 352 E Stewart St, Milwaukee, WI 53207

This Bay View favorite offers creative Italian dishes in a cozy neighborhood setting. From fresh pasta to seasonal specials, Santino’s Little Italy has earned a loyal following among Milwaukee diners looking for elevated Italian food.

8. Dorsia

Get Directions: 1307 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202

One of Milwaukee’s newer Italian-inspired destinations, Dorsia has quickly become known for its sophisticated atmosphere, handmade pasta and attention to detail. It’s an excellent option for special occasions or a memorable night out.

9. Zarletti

Get Directions: 741 N Milwaukee St, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Zarletti is located in the heart of downtown and specializes in Northern Italian cuisine and fresh, seasonal ingredients. The elegant dining room and carefully crafted menu have made it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

10. Sorella

Get Directions: 2535 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Nestled in the heart of Bay View, Sorella brings a vibrant, neighborhood-centric energy to Milwaukee’s Italian scene. Known for its wood-fired pizzas, comforting Southern Italian-inspired small plates, and a welcoming, stylish atmosphere, it’s the perfect spot for sharing a relaxed meal with friends or family.

Explore Milwaukee’s Italian Food Scene With Us

Whether you’re craving handmade pasta, a perfect meatball sandwich, authentic Sicilian specialties or a wood-fired pizza, Milwaukee’s Italian restaurant scene offers something for everyone.

Join us on our Brady Street Food Tour and experience Milwaukee’s most beloved Italian institutions firsthand including Glorioso’s Italian Market. It’s a chance to explore the rich history of Brady Street while tasting local favorites along the way.

Find your next culinary adventure. View our tour calendar today and experience the best food and flavors Milwaukee has to offer. 

You Might Also Like

A Local Guide to the Best Italian Bakeries in Milwaukee: Traditions, Breads, and Treats

What Are the Best Restaurants in the Historic Third Ward in Milwaukee, WI?

The Best Mexican Restaurants in Milwaukee for Tacos, Margaritas, and More